Decking – Composite vs Wood Boards & Railings

Apr 6, 2026 | Blog Post

Composite Decking Boards vs Wood Decking Boards

What’s the difference? Composite is a board made typically of wood fibers, plastic or polyethylene and some additives to help with UV, Moisture, etc.  They often come with different grades and colors available.  One big thing that I like to point out to my customers is the “amount of board” that you get per linear foot depending on the price range.  Below is an example of a few boards to show what they look like.

You can see in the boards above that they have varying amout of actual material in the board.  This allows pricing to show better for the boards with less actual material.  Wood decking boards are always solid.

You will also notice the first image shows the grooves on the side of the board, this is the style board you need to use when you want clips to hold down the boards instead of a screw going from the top of the board down.  More on this later in this post.

This image shows rough pricing for a 16 foot decking board comparing different compsoite boards to wood decking boards. This is information based on April 2026 pricing. It shows boards with less materials vs more solid boards and the price difference.  To give an idea of the price difference for an average deck.

10 foot x 16 foot deck, relatively average sized deck in the suburbs.  

Replacing your deck boards with just material cost based on the above.  We’re going to use Trex Select at an average of $66 per board and Southern Yellow Pine pressure treated lumber.

Composite Trex Select Boards – $1452.00

Southern Yellow Pine Board – $396.00

You can see that going with composite that you’re going to spend a little over 3x the pricing on composite vs wood deck boards.

Now for the labor, the more expensive part of any project in todays world.  This labor is based on our company being in the Philadelphia Suburbs so potentially higher than other parts of the country with cost of living. 

Composite Board Install

Hidden Fastners – Picture Frame Style Install – Just Decking Board Install 

$3060.00

Wood Board Install

Exterior Decking Screws – Installed Top/Down – Standard Horizontal Install – Just Board Install

$1360.00

You can see the difference in price is not small, this is just a basic idea to give you some idea of the cost difference.  The reason for additional labor to install composite boards is these require additional framing to your joists below to allow a “picture frame style” install which is needed since the inside of the boards is not colored and you do not want to see the non colored on the sides of your deck.  They also require more labor to install the clips to have no screw holes vs standard screws through the boards.  Lastly, clips can only be used on the interior horizontal boards so also we would need to use a color matched screw with plug to hide the screw holes for the exterior picture frame of the deck.

Does composite decking last forever? Zero Maintenance and Lasts forever… never need to spend any money on my deck again…

Simply put, NO.  It does not last forever and it will need to be replaced.  Composite decking is similar to wood decking, it lasts about 20 years.  Companies such as Trex, Fiberon, etc have done an amazing job with marketing to make the public believe that their products last forever.  They have done a great job making you believe that their warranty will cover your deck forever… that’s not the case.  Most of the manufacturer warranties void themselves out almost immediatly once installing in a climate with direct sunlight, snow, ice, rain, shade, etc.

This is a 20 year old composite deck

Over the years, I have now seen and replaced 100’s of composite decks that the previous homeowner installed or the current installed thinking it was going to last forever.  It’s a very common misconception that I try to warn every homeowner I meet about it.  

Now, wood is not any better.  Wood does require maintenance.  The benefit is that wood is tremendously cheaper, however you do need to maintain it.  I do tell everyone, 

Staining a Wood Deck every 3 years, will result in 20+ years of your deck lasting and potentially out lasting a composite deck

Stain is the key though, not paint.  Stain gets absorbed into the wood protecting outside and inside of the wood vs paint just sits on the surface.  Paint will need to be kept up with annually vs stain can go 3 years without needing touch ups.  I will say we do see the “semi solid” stains needing more maintenance annually than a less solid stain that can go the three years.  

Once other thing is that it’s important to wait to stain any deck board until it’s completely dry from the inside out, meaning if it’s a brand new board from the lumber yard that was just installed you need to give it 1-3 months in hot weather to full dry out first before staining it.  The pressure treating process has mositure throughout the entire board including the inside of it, they do get dried in the sun in manufacturing process however not long enough with supply and demand and they still get to lumber yards pretty wet.

My Opinion for your Deck

Go with wood boards, pay someone every 3 years to power wash and re stain your deck boards.  You will see the price being around $300 approx every 3 years depending on size of deck.  The first stain is always more due to cracks and crevices to get it sealed up well but after that it’s typically more surface needs.  The $300 every 3 years is a total of $2000 over the course of 20 years which is still cheaper than composite boards from day one between labor and material costs to install them.

Clip Install vs Screw Down Install

Clip install is on composite boards where the clip slides into the groove on the side of the deck boards and is installed with a built in screw to the clip that secures the board to the joists.  My biggest issue and what I see with this, half of your board is being held down.  The other half is not being held down.  When you use a screw from the top of the board down into the joist you’re getting the full board being held down.  Composite and Wood, they both like to warp over time.  When half the board is being held down, warping is more likely.  When the full board is being held down, warping is less likely. Installing with nails is just a NO across the board, never a good idea ever.   One thing you can do with composite if you go that route, use color matched screws and plugs, they’re more labor intensive to install but gives you the top down install and the color match plug goes into the hole created by screw to help hide the screw holes.

Composite Railings vs Wood Railings

I am a very firm believer that composite railings are the way to go, I am not a fan of wood railings.  My reason is simple, wood railings require staining and or painting to maintain them which is time consuming which means more expensive to maintain.  Staining deck boards with a roller takes an hour or two depending on the size of your deck, staining the spindles and posts of a railing can take tremendously more time.  Wood railings due to the size of materials and in the NorthEast having snow sitting on top of them tend to rot faster than deck boards.  

Composite railings if you stay simple and go with very basic white vinyl railings with spindles can be around the same price maybe 10% more in material cost but labor to install is lower.  When you start to get into black railings, wire railings, aluminum black railings, color matched railings, lights in posts, etc then the price can go up rather quickly and you can spend $10k + just on just the railings alone.

The deck pictured above that we did in the Summer 2025 has the very basic white vinyl railings installed on it.  These come out to be around $110 per 8 foot section of railing in material cost.

View of a sunny suburban backyard from a wooden deck with shadows of the railing

This deck picture above was built with Trex Decking Boards and Trex Color Matched railings, the railings per 8 foot section on this deck were around $347

You can see the difference in price can add up quickly, an average deck with no stairs is going to have 5-7 sections of railing so just material cost can be 3x not including labor which is relatively similar between the railings and it’s more of a material cost.

In Conclusion

I hope this post helps you a bit with your next deck project, decks are an amazing way to enjoy the spring, summer and early fall months outside especially in our area where we only get to use our decks about 5 months out of the year consistently, it’s a great way to increase livable square fottage of your home during this time of year and enjoy the space with your family.

We’re A to Z Family Business, I am the owner Derek Anasiewicz and I am obsessed with being honest and transparent and helping homeowners navigate the home residential remodeling world that unforunately gets a bad rap.

Search

Latest Posts

Request Free Estimate

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*